Post by charybdis on Jun 18, 2009 11:58:09 GMT -5
I have recently reread the Battlestar Galactica Saga of a Star World novelization and it dawned on me the differences between the novel and the tv show. I thought I would write down those differences so anyone who has not read the novel can see how it was a bit different.
I have broken up the types of information into two categories:
expositional - the information does not contradict what was seen in the tv show, it just tells us more about a topic;
contradictory - the information contradicts what was seen in the tv show.
Battlestar Galactica novelization:
* Zac is a battle-hardened Lieutenant, not an Ensign on his first patrol (contradictory)
*Zac is assigned the mission with Apollo by Col. Tigh as punishment because he was caught fooling around with one of Dr. Paye's nurses (contradictory)
* To engage the Viper's turbo engines, a pedal must be pushed (contradictory)
* President Adar has a long, gray beard (contradictory)
* Baltar is very fat (contradictory)
* Baltar is a self-proclaimed count who was a trader in rare items (expositional)
* The fleet is said to have 5 battlestars (expositional)
* The Battlestar Pacifica was said to have been the largest battlestar but she had already been destroyed thus making the Galactica the fleet's largest (contradictory)
* The Galactica was commissioned 200 years ago.(expositional)
* Commander Adama has commanded the Galactica for 25 years (expositional)
* Jolly's and Greenbeans' names were given to them by their squadron mates due to their appearances (expositional)
* Cylons are actual creatures who have many eyes on their heads and can change the shape of their heads at will (contradictory)
* Athena has blonde hair (contradictory)
* Vipers have to taxi to their launch point (contradictory)
* There are battle cruisers with the fleet indicating another type of warship (expositional)
* The Imperious Leader is 700 years old (expositional)
* Imperious Leaders serve a term of 75 years (expositional)
* Boxey is not Serina's son (contradictory)
* There is a camouflage force field around the Galactica and the fleet (contradictory)
* Prina is Serina's sound technician on Caprica (expositional)
* Morel is Serina's cameraman (expositional)
* One of the other battlestars at Cimtar is the Solaria (contradictory)
* The rag tag fleet is composed of 22,000 ships (contradictory)
* Cassiopiea is dark haired and has dark eyes (contradictory)
* Sire Uri is actually arrested and taken away from his party onboard the Rising Star (contradictory)
* Adama resigns as President of the Council of the Twelve (contradictory)
* It is Adama's idea to go to Carillon, not Apollo's (contradictory)
* Some of the ships jump to the Carillon sector and leave the rest behind (contradictory)
* They are surprised to find that the approach to Carillon is mined (contradictory)
* It is Adama's plan to clear the mines, not Apollo's (contradictory)
* There is no Nova of Madagon (contradictory)
* The viper scanners do not work in the minefield (contradictory)
* There are three types of mines, one which just explodes on contact, another that gives off a blinding flash of light, and the third are electronic jammers (contradictory)
* Apollo, Boomer and Starbuck fly blind and form a wedge to blow a path through the minefield (sort of contradictory)
* Some Cylon worlds practice monogamy and the IL vows to stamp it out (contradictory)
* A whole crop can grow in one day (expositional)
* Ovions were enslaved and transported to Carillon by the Cylons (expositional)
* Adama goes down to Carillon (contradictory)
* Apollo wears dress blues on Carillon as do most of the other warriors (contradictory)
* Lotay, the Ovion queen, has drugged the leaders to influence them into staying (contradictory)
* The three warrior "imposters" who Apollo and Starbuck chase into the elevator are captured by the Ovions (expositional)
* The three "imposters" are then rescued by Apollo and Starbuck (contradictory)
* Starbuck kills Lotay (contradictory)
* Muffit is shot by a Cylon (contradictory)
* Col. Tigh is on Carillon at the ceremony (contradictory)
* Col. Tigh is wounded in the ground battle (contradictory)
* Rain is falling as the Colonials evacuate Carillon (contradictory)
* Starbuck and Cassiopiea pilot an Ovion transport full of Tylium up to the Galactica (contradictory)
* No direct mention is made of Carillon actually exploding, although they do mention the possibility of it occurring with all of the Tylium on fire (contradictory)
* The Imperious Leader is not present at Carillon and therefore does not die (contradictory)
* Baltar is executed (contradictory in tv version)
* Sire Uri resigns from the council (expositional)
* The Cylons are defeated at Carillon but another force attacks the fleet ships which had been left behind by the Galactica (contradictory)
* The Galactica and vipers jump back to the fleet and rout the Cylons there as well (contradictory)
* They eat mashed potatoes (expositional)
Those are the main things I noticed as I read. What do you think?
I have broken up the types of information into two categories:
expositional - the information does not contradict what was seen in the tv show, it just tells us more about a topic;
contradictory - the information contradicts what was seen in the tv show.
Battlestar Galactica novelization:
* Zac is a battle-hardened Lieutenant, not an Ensign on his first patrol (contradictory)
*Zac is assigned the mission with Apollo by Col. Tigh as punishment because he was caught fooling around with one of Dr. Paye's nurses (contradictory)
* To engage the Viper's turbo engines, a pedal must be pushed (contradictory)
* President Adar has a long, gray beard (contradictory)
* Baltar is very fat (contradictory)
* Baltar is a self-proclaimed count who was a trader in rare items (expositional)
* The fleet is said to have 5 battlestars (expositional)
* The Battlestar Pacifica was said to have been the largest battlestar but she had already been destroyed thus making the Galactica the fleet's largest (contradictory)
* The Galactica was commissioned 200 years ago.(expositional)
* Commander Adama has commanded the Galactica for 25 years (expositional)
* Jolly's and Greenbeans' names were given to them by their squadron mates due to their appearances (expositional)
* Cylons are actual creatures who have many eyes on their heads and can change the shape of their heads at will (contradictory)
* Athena has blonde hair (contradictory)
* Vipers have to taxi to their launch point (contradictory)
* There are battle cruisers with the fleet indicating another type of warship (expositional)
* The Imperious Leader is 700 years old (expositional)
* Imperious Leaders serve a term of 75 years (expositional)
* Boxey is not Serina's son (contradictory)
* There is a camouflage force field around the Galactica and the fleet (contradictory)
* Prina is Serina's sound technician on Caprica (expositional)
* Morel is Serina's cameraman (expositional)
* One of the other battlestars at Cimtar is the Solaria (contradictory)
* The rag tag fleet is composed of 22,000 ships (contradictory)
* Cassiopiea is dark haired and has dark eyes (contradictory)
* Sire Uri is actually arrested and taken away from his party onboard the Rising Star (contradictory)
* Adama resigns as President of the Council of the Twelve (contradictory)
* It is Adama's idea to go to Carillon, not Apollo's (contradictory)
* Some of the ships jump to the Carillon sector and leave the rest behind (contradictory)
* They are surprised to find that the approach to Carillon is mined (contradictory)
* It is Adama's plan to clear the mines, not Apollo's (contradictory)
* There is no Nova of Madagon (contradictory)
* The viper scanners do not work in the minefield (contradictory)
* There are three types of mines, one which just explodes on contact, another that gives off a blinding flash of light, and the third are electronic jammers (contradictory)
* Apollo, Boomer and Starbuck fly blind and form a wedge to blow a path through the minefield (sort of contradictory)
* Some Cylon worlds practice monogamy and the IL vows to stamp it out (contradictory)
* A whole crop can grow in one day (expositional)
* Ovions were enslaved and transported to Carillon by the Cylons (expositional)
* Adama goes down to Carillon (contradictory)
* Apollo wears dress blues on Carillon as do most of the other warriors (contradictory)
* Lotay, the Ovion queen, has drugged the leaders to influence them into staying (contradictory)
* The three warrior "imposters" who Apollo and Starbuck chase into the elevator are captured by the Ovions (expositional)
* The three "imposters" are then rescued by Apollo and Starbuck (contradictory)
* Starbuck kills Lotay (contradictory)
* Muffit is shot by a Cylon (contradictory)
* Col. Tigh is on Carillon at the ceremony (contradictory)
* Col. Tigh is wounded in the ground battle (contradictory)
* Rain is falling as the Colonials evacuate Carillon (contradictory)
* Starbuck and Cassiopiea pilot an Ovion transport full of Tylium up to the Galactica (contradictory)
* No direct mention is made of Carillon actually exploding, although they do mention the possibility of it occurring with all of the Tylium on fire (contradictory)
* The Imperious Leader is not present at Carillon and therefore does not die (contradictory)
* Baltar is executed (contradictory in tv version)
* Sire Uri resigns from the council (expositional)
* The Cylons are defeated at Carillon but another force attacks the fleet ships which had been left behind by the Galactica (contradictory)
* The Galactica and vipers jump back to the fleet and rout the Cylons there as well (contradictory)
* They eat mashed potatoes (expositional)
Those are the main things I noticed as I read. What do you think?